Approach to the Dense Brunescent Cataract

With Increased Nuclear Density comes Increased Risks

Here is how to successfully approach these tough cataract surgery cases:

Patients with dense brunescent cataracts have typically delayed having cataract surgery for many years. During this time the nuclear sclerosis progresses to the point where it causes additional challenges and poses higher risks for complications. For some patients fear is the reason why they keep postponing surgery, whereas for others, lack of access to healthcare is the primary problem. With a careful approach and modified techniques, we can perform safe cataract surgery and restore vision to these patients.

Pre-Operative Consultation

Often other ocular co-morbidities are present in these patients. The visual deprivation from the cataract can induce a sensory exotropia, particularly if one eye has significantly worse vision than the other. As the nuclear sclerosis progresses, the crystalline lens can increase in anterior-posterior dimension which can lead to shallowing of the anterior chamber and narrowing of the angle. Sometimes a brunescent cataract, particularly if it is unilateral, can be associated with prior trauma or previous ocular surgery such as a pars plana vitrectomy.

Optical coherence biometry can usually measure the axial length in these eyes, but in cases where the cataract is just too opaque, A-scan ultrasound may be required. The pupillary dilation should be measured because a sufficiently large capsulorhexis will be needed during cataract surgery. The brunescent cataract can also induce a myopic shift in the refraction, so a discussion of the intended post-operative refractive target should be included in the consultation. Finally, the patients should understand that their specific type of cataract does pose additional surgical challenges and risks. The increased amount of ultrasound using during phacoemulsification of a brunescent cataract will induce more corneal edema and delay the visual recovery.


Intra-Operative Techniques

Anticipate that surgery for a dense brunescent cataract will take longer than a typical case, and consider supplementing the anesthesia. These cases can still be performed with topical and intra-cameral anesthesia, but care should be taken to keep the patient comfortable and pain-free. Using additional local anesthesia midway through the case can be helpful. For more challenging cases, a peri-bulbar or retro-bulbar block may be helpful.

A standard limbal or corneal phaco incision can be used in these cases, but consider a scleral tunnel if you anticipate that there is a chance that you will need to convert to a manual extra-capsular extraction. Because more ultrasound phaco energy will be used to emulsify the cataract, the risk of a phaco wound burn is increased. This can be mitigated by having a slightly leaky incision, floating in the center of the incision instead of pressing on the corneal tissue, and by using phaco power modulations. Phaco power modulations such as a variable duty cycle, pulse and burst modes, and torsional ultrasound delivery can all assist in keeping the cumulative energy relatively low and the phaco tip cooler.

A generous capsulorhexis should be made with a diameter of about 5 to 5.5 millimeters to allow easy access to the cataract. In a routine case with only moderate nuclear sclerosis there is a smaller endo-nucleus with increased density surrounded by a zone of softer epi-nucleus and then cortical material. However in a brunescent cataract the entire nucleus is dense with essentially no epi-nucleus, and this requires a larger capsulorhexis to facilitate cataract extraction. If the red reflex and visibility is hindered by the brunescent cataract, trypan blue dye can be used to stain the anterior lens capsule.

Some surgeons may attempt to use a femto-second laser to help fragment or soften the lens nucleus, but penetration of the laser energy depends on the opacity of the cataract. The brunescent cataract tends to be fibrous or leathery, particularly at the posterior portion of the lens and this can make it difficult to cleave into distinct nuclear pieces. Some surgeons use mechanical devices, such as lassos or sharp cleaving instruments, to split the cataract prior to phacoemulsification.

The brunescent cataract typically has a dense, fibrous posterior plate that is difficult to split with traditional techniques such as divide-and-conquer or horizontal chop. My preferred technique involves partially prolapsing one part of the nucleus above the capsulorhexis edge in order to place the chopper behind the posterior pole of the cataract (figure 1). This can be done by gentle hyrodissection, though care must be taken to avoid blowing out the posterior capsule, or by placing the chopper around the lens equator and lifting the cataract up out of the bag.

Once the nucleus is partially prolapsed, dispersive viscoelastic is injected between the cataract and posterior capsule and then again to recoat the corneal endothelial surface.  The chopper is placed directly behind the posterior pole of the cataract while the phaco probe is embedded into the anterior portion of the cataract. The two instruments are then brought together and then pulled in opposite directions to cleave the cataract into two halves (figure 2). Each half can then be subdivided into smaller pieces by further chopping (figure 3). As pieces of the nucleus are cleaved and then phaco-aspirated, additional viscoelastic can be used to recoat the corneal endothelium.  When the last nuclear piece is being removed, the smooth side of the chopper can be placed under the phaco tip to ensure that the posterior capsule is kept at a safe distance. Once the cortex is removed, the IOL is inserted into the capsular bag and centered with the capsulorhexis overlapping the optic edge for stability (figure 4).

Post-Operative Course

These patients are expected to have a longer post-op recovery period due to the larger amount of phaco energy used in removing the dense brunescent cataract. Additional steroids may be helpful in reducing inflammation and aiding the cornea in resolution of any induced edema. After the eye has healed, these patients are incredibly happy since the improvement in vision is so dramatic. Dense brunescent cataracts are challenging, even for the expert surgeon, but with careful planning and a stepwise approach, they can be successfully treated and vision can be restored to our patients.


Figure 1: The dense brunescent cataract is partially prolapsed above the capsulorhexis edge in order to provide access to posterior aspect of the nucleus.



Figure 2: The chopper instrument is placed behind the tilted nucleus while the phaco probe is embedded into the anterior surface. The instruments are then brought together and then pulled in opposite directions to chop the nucleus into two halves.



Figure 3: The nuclear halves are then subdivided into smaller fragments using the phaco-chop technique.



Figure 4: At the end of the case, the lens implant is placed within the capsular bag and secured with an overlap of the capsulorhexis over the optic edge.


Here is a video of the entire case with voiceover teaching:


Uday Devgan, MD is in private practice at Devgan Eye Surgery in Los Angeles, partner at Specialty Surgical Center in Beverly Hills, Chief of Ophthalmology at Olive View-UCLA Medical Center, and award-winning Clinical Professor of Ophthalmology at the Jules Stein Eye Institute, UCLA School of Medicine.



  1. Thank you for sharing this case in real time, Uday. Many wonderful pearls and most enjoyable to learn from the Cataract Coach!

  2. Thanks so much Dr Devgan! The world needs more wonderful doctors like you that are willing to teach and share with your colleagues. I’m not much of a chop cataract surgeon. How would you approach this same case if you had to use D&Q?

    Thanks again so much!!

    1. thanks for visiting the site — and thanks for the kind feedback. The difficulty in this case is the dense, fibrous posterior plate which is difficult to split when doing divide and conquer. Certainly D+C will work, but it will not be easy. That’s why I prefer the technique of getting the nucleus out of the bag to access the posterior lens plate with the chopper. Next week I will have a video of flip-and-chop which is easier to learn if you’re coming from D+C. Check it out.

  3. I see you don’t monetize your site, don’t waste your traffic, you can earn extra cash every month.
    You can use the best adsense alternative for any type of website (they approve all websites), for more info simply search
    in gooogle: boorfe’s tips monetize your website

Leave a Reply